Where to Stay in Key West
Imagine a place where the sun always shines, where turquoise waters lap against historic shores, and where every sunset is a celebration. Welcome to Key West, Florida, a vibrant island paradise at the very end of the Overseas Highway. This enchanting destination isn’t just a dot on the map; it’s a state of mind, brimming with quirky charm, rich history, and an infectious laid-back vibe.
From the lively pulse of Duval Street to the serene beauty of hidden gardens, Key West offers a kaleidoscope of experiences for every type of traveler. You will discover a unique blend of Caribbean flair and American heritage, where legendary figures like Ernest Hemingway found inspiration and where a vibrant arts scene thrives. To truly immerse yourself in the magic, consider visiting during the shoulder seasons of late spring (April-May) or early fall (October-November) when the weather is glorious, and the crowds are thinner, offering the perfect balance for exploring its distinct neighborhoods and iconic attractions. Get ready to uncover the secrets of this southernmost gem and find your perfect slice of paradise.
💰 Travel Cost Overview
| Category | Budget | Mid-range | Luxury |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accommodation per night | $150 – $250 | $250 – $450 | $450 – $800+ |
| Food & Dining per day | $45 – $80 | $80 – $180 | $180 – $400+ |
| Transportation per day | $0 – $20 (walking/bus) | $20 – $70 (bike/scooter) | $70 – $150+ (car rental/taxi) |
| Activities & Attractions per day | $0 – $30 (free sites/beach) | $30 – $100 (1-2 museums/tours) | $100 – $300+ (multiple tours/charters) |
| Total Daily Budget (Low) | $195 | $350 | $700 |
| Total Daily Budget (Medium) | $270 | $500 | $900 |
| Total Daily Budget (High) | $350 | $700 | $1200+ |
| Weekly Budget Estimates | $1365 – $2450 | $2450 – $4900 | $4900 – $8400+ |
Mallory Square
Mallory Square is the beating heart of Key West’s communal spirit, globally renowned for its nightly Sunset Celebration. What makes this place truly unique is the collective energy that gathers here an hour or two before dusk. You will find an eclectic assembly of street performers, artisans, and food vendors all contributing to a festive atmosphere that feels like a permanent carnival. Expect to see jugglers, magicians, musicians, and even tightrope walkers captivating crowds against the backdrop of the setting sun. The air fills with the scent of street food and the sounds of laughter and applause, creating an unforgettable sensory experience.
As the sun dips below the horizon, painting the sky in fiery oranges and purples, a collective cheer often erupts from the crowd, a testament to the shared magic of the moment. This is where the local and tourist communities merge, celebrating a tradition that embodies the island’s laid-back yet vibrant culture. It is an absolute must-do for anyone visiting Key West, offering a genuine taste of its unique charm. This experience is perfect for families, couples, and solo travelers alike, providing entertainment and a stunning natural spectacle. The history of Mallory Square as a hub for sponge docks and fishing vessels adds a layer of authenticity to its transformation into this beloved public square.
💰 Quick Cost Guide
📍 Visitor Information
Old Town/ Key West Historic District
Stepping into Old Town, also known as the Key West Historic District, is like turning the pages of a living history book. This charming area is a labyrinth of narrow streets lined with beautifully preserved 19th-century Victorian homes, many adorned with gingerbread trim and lush tropical gardens. What makes it special is the architectural integrity and the stories held within its walls. You will discover iconic landmarks such as the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, where the famous author lived and wrote, and the Harry S.
Truman Little White House, Florida’s only presidential museum. Beyond the famous sites, Old Town invites you to simply wander, soak in the atmosphere, and stumble upon hidden gems like quaint B&Bs, art galleries, and independent boutiques. The district’s unique character is shaped by its past as a prosperous port town, evident in its sturdy, hurricane-resistant “Conch” houses built by shipbuilders. Best explored on foot or by bicycle, you can spend hours admiring the unique architecture, stopping for a coffee, or visiting one of the many small museums. It is ideal for history buffs, architecture enthusiasts, couples seeking romantic strolls, and anyone who appreciates a slower pace and rich cultural immersion.
💰 Quick Cost Guide
📍 Visitor Information
New Town
New Town, often overlooked by tourists who flock to the historic core, offers a different facet of Key West life. This area, located east of the Old Town, is primarily residential and commercial, providing a glimpse into where locals live, work, and shop. What makes New Town unique is its contrast to the bustling historic district; it is quieter, more spacious, and offers a practical side to island living. You will find larger chain stores, supermarkets, and more affordable dining options here, making it a great place to stock up on essentials if you are staying in a self-catering accommodation.
It is also home to some larger resorts and hotels that offer more amenities and often better parking than their Old Town counterparts. While it lacks the historical charm of Old Town, New Town provides a necessary infrastructure for the island and is where many residents find their everyday conveniences. It is perfect for budget-conscious travelers, families looking for more space, or those who prefer a quieter base and don’t mind a short drive or bus ride to the main attractions. It also features some local parks and recreation areas that offer a more authentic community feel.
💰 Quick Cost Guide
📍 Visitor Information
Smathers Beach
Smathers Beach is Key West’s largest public beach, offering a classic Florida Keys experience with its crescent of imported white sand and calm, clear waters. What sets it apart in Key West, an island not typically known for its expansive beaches, is its sheer size and array of activities. You will find palm trees swaying gently in the breeze, perfect for providing natural shade, and a vibrant atmosphere with options for water sports rentals. Expect to see people sunbathing, swimming, paddleboarding, kayaking, and even parasailing. The calm, shallow waters make it ideal for families with children, offering a safe environment for splashing around.
There are also volleyball nets available, inviting spontaneous games. The beach is maintained and offers amenities like restrooms and food trucks, ensuring a comfortable visit. Smathers Beach is a wonderful escape from the hustle and bustle of Duval Street, providing a tranquil spot to relax and enjoy the island’s natural beauty. It is excellent for families, sun-seekers, water sports enthusiasts, and anyone looking to unwind by the ocean without venturing far. Its history as a man-made beach underscores the island’s commitment to providing accessible coastal recreation.
💰 Quick Cost Guide
📍 Visitor Information
Duval Street
Duval Street is the undisputed entertainment hub of Key West, a vibrant artery stretching from the Atlantic Ocean to the Gulf of Mexico. What makes it unique is its intoxicating blend of history, hedonism, and sheer exuberance. You will discover a continuous parade of colorful bars, live music venues, art galleries, souvenir shops, and restaurants, each with its own distinct character. Expect to hear reggae, rock, and pop spilling from open doorways, inviting you to step inside and join the party.
From iconic watering holes like Sloppy Joe’s, a favorite of Ernest Hemingway, to quieter spots offering craft cocktails, there is a vibe for every taste. While known for its nightlife, Duval Street is equally fascinating during the day, offering opportunities for shopping, people-watching, and exploring its many intriguing storefronts and historic buildings. The street pulses with an energy that is uniquely Key West, reflecting its history as a melting pot of cultures and a haven for free spirits. It is perfect for those seeking lively entertainment, a taste of Key West’s legendary nightlife, or simply an exciting place to stroll and absorb the island’s vibrant energy.
💰 Quick Cost Guide
📍 Visitor Information
Bahama Village
Bahama Village is a historic and culturally rich neighborhood located just west of Duval Street, offering a refreshing contrast to the tourist bustle. What makes it unique is its authentic Caribbean ambiance, distinct from the rest of Key West. You will discover colorful wooden houses, lush tropical foliage, and a strong sense of community, reflecting its roots as a settlement for Bahamian immigrants in the 19th century. Expect to find a delightful array of independent shops selling unique arts, crafts, and clothing, alongside some of the island’s most beloved local restaurants and cafes.
This area is less about grand attractions and more about soaking in the atmosphere, exploring charming backstreets, and discovering hidden culinary gems. It is home to the famous Blue Heaven restaurant, known for its outdoor dining under a canopy of trees and its resident chickens. Bahama Village truly offers a glimpse into Key West’s diverse cultural heritage and provides a more laid-back, authentic experience. It is ideal for foodies, culture enthusiasts, shoppers looking for unique finds, and anyone seeking a more genuine local feel away from the main tourist drag.
💰 Quick Cost Guide
📍 Visitor Information
Historic Seaport
The Historic Seaport, often referred to as the “Bight,” is a bustling and picturesque working harbor that perfectly encapsulates Key West’s maritime heritage. What makes it special is its vibrant blend of active fishing boats, charter vessels, waterside restaurants, and charming boardwalks. You will discover a dynamic scene where fishing boats unload their daily catch, offering the freshest seafood, and where a multitude of excursions depart. Expect to see historic schooners, modern catamarans, and sleek yachts lining the docks, ready for sunset cruises, snorkeling trips, dolphin watching tours, or fishing charters.
The boardwalks are lined with inviting restaurants, many with outdoor seating, where you can savor fresh seafood while watching the boats come and go. Beyond the tours, the Seaport is a fantastic place for a leisurely stroll, offering stunning views of the water and the chance to observe marine life. Its history as the heart of Key West’s fishing and trade industries is palpable, giving it an authentic, salty charm. It is perfect for adventure seekers, food lovers, families looking for boat excursions, and anyone who appreciates a lively waterfront atmosphere.
💰 Quick Cost Guide
📍 Visitor Information
Plan Your Visit
Key West truly is a destination unlike any other, offering an incredible tapestry of experiences that cater to every interest and budget. From the electrifying energy of Mallory Square’s Sunset Celebration and Duval Street’s legendary nightlife, to the tranquil shores of Smathers Beach and the historic charm of Old Town, you will discover that each neighborhood tells its own unique story. Explore the cultural richness of Bahama Village or the practical side of New Town, and immerse yourself in the vibrant maritime life of the Historic Seaport.
This guide has provided a glimpse into the diverse attractions and the practicalities of visiting, including detailed cost insights to help you plan your ideal trip. Whether you are seeking adventure on the water, a deep dive into history, or simply a laid-back escape, Key West promises an unforgettable journey. So pack your bags, embrace the island’s quirky spirit, and prepare to be captivated by the magic of this southernmost paradise. Your Key West adventure awaits!
